My last show of the season at this year's Shaw Festival in Niagara-on-the-Lake was well worth the wait...the classic thriller "Wait Until Dark".
I knew of the play and later the movie of course. Frederick Knott's play hit broadway in 1966 and met with great success. The 1967 film that followed was a classic, starring Audrey Hepburn as Susy and Alan Arkin as Harry Roat, Jr. Oddly enough, I had never seen either the play nor the movie before attending the current production at Shaw; I was most familiar with the movie soundtrack provided by Henry Mancini. Well I am a musical person after all!
Perhaps not seeing an earlier production of "Wait Until Dark" is not a bad thing, really, as I went in as a virgin, as it were, and let it work its magic on me for the very first time. And that it did.
The original by Knott was updated by Jeffrey Hatcher in 2013 and the play was moved from the Greenwich Village of the 60s all the way back to the 40s, and to my eyes it just seems to work better. We see characters right at home in a 40s-era thriller and not one of them seems out of place.
"Wait Until Dark" involves Susan, a blind woman who lost her vision a few years earlier in an accident and managing to make her way in the world that has totally changed for her. At this moment in time however, her husband is out of town after the two of them acquired a musical doll for some reason. But the doll is more than just musical. There is something valuable inside.
Enter a bunch of thugs who figure it will be easy pickings getting the doll and the enclosed valuables back from Susan while she's alone. She's blind after all...but...she is far from helpless. We meet Carlino, posing as a hard-nosed detective, played by Martin Happer. He is working with Roat, played by Bruce Horak, and returning serviceman Mike, supposedly an old friend of husband Sam, played by Kristopher Bowman.
Susan has no reason to suspect Carlino nor Mike are anything other than what they say they are, but over the course of the play she starts to figure it out and realizes her life is in real danger. It is then her steely resolve takes over and she has to outsmart them. This she undertakes with the help of the only true friend she has at the moment, a prostitute and neighbour in the apartment building, Gloria, played by Eponine Lee.
The first act is rather long, building up to the pivotal second act which is played out in darkness but not completely due to theatre lighting. It is then Susan is no longer the only one with a visual disadvantage and she makes it work for her with her heightened senses due to her lack of eyesight.
Director Sanjay Talwar keeps the tension building throughout and has an excellent cast at his disposal. As Susan, Sochi Fried is both sweet and trusting until she can't afford to be; her performance is outstanding. Happer is just seedy enough to fit the bill of a 40s-era hard-nosed detective to a "T".
Bruce Horak as Roat, in several guises throughout the play, is fascinating to watch, especially when we realize in real life Horak is himself visually impaired. Yet he navigates the stage with little problem throughout the play.
As Gloria, Eponine Lee is cocky, smart-ass and just enough help for Susan when she needs to be. This is a finely drawn characterization. Towards the end of the play we finally meet Susan's husband Sam, played by J.J. Gerber, as he returns home from his trip just in time.
The stage set is spare with a very long staircase indicating this is a basement apartment, but because of the huge space on the Festival stage, a rather large one. But if I have one real complaint about the set it is the apartment door at the top of the stairs. It sounds like nothing more than a closet door, when it should sound heftier and look more secure given this is Greenwich Village after all. But that's a minor quibble.
Sure the play is showing its age a little bit, even with Hatcher's updating in 2013, but with the right cast and direction as we have in this Shaw production, "Wait Until Dark" still packs an emotional punch for today's audiences.
"Wait Until Dark" runs at the Festival Theatre until October 5th and rates a strong three out of four stars. For tickets and information go to www.shawfest.com.
Enjoy your week!
August 12th, 2025.